Back in grade school, I remember one time we had brainstorming and problem-solving exercises. I think it was in history class, but who knows.
Anyway, outside of class, I thought up some ideas of my own. I think they were for my newsletter I was doing at the time; I had subscribers numbering perhaps under a dozen, but I wrote for an audience of hundreds. At any rate, today I remembered one of those ethical questions. I don’t know if I ever published it, but here is basically what it was…
On an island, a snake is found whose venom can cure all major diseases. Cancer, heart disease, diabetes–all cured. The venom cannot be synthesized, so the only way to produce it in quantity is to raise these snakes. The problem is that the snakes are man-eating snakes, and cannot survive on any other food source. What would you do?
Bear in mind that I came up with this in grade school. Realistically, a snake that feeds only on humans probably isn’t very likely at all. What would there be that the snake would be unable to get from wild hogs or another large mammal? And, even if it was something specific to humans, surely we could come up with a dietary supplement for the snakes. Maybe feed the snakes pigs and supplement it with whatever is needed from the human body. Maybe there would be volunteers to give blood or bone marrow or whatever it is the snakes need. But, let’s put all that aside, and go back to the grade school mentality…
What we have is a snake. It’s venom is a cure-all, but the snakes can only survive on a diet of live people. Not cadavers, live. So, the only way to keep these snakes alive would be to toss live people into their cages as food. Presumably, these snakes were discovered on a populated island, but where the people were perhaps very primitive and not in contact with the civilized world.
What would you do? Would you let the snakes go extinct, and keep samples of the venom for study, in the hopes that one day it might be synthesized? Or, do you feed the snakes convicted murderers and so forth, even though they’ll have deaths that are far from humane?
And, if you oppose feeding live people to the snakes, what if people in other countries weren’t as unwilling as you? Would you buy the cure-all venom from them if they offered it for sale? How would your decision be affected if you or a loved one were dying from something the venom could cure?